Follow for more talkers

Studies

Those born into money may more sensitive to the plight of the poor

“Just because someone has been in your shoes, doesn’t necessarily mean they care about you."

Published

on

By Danny Halpin via SWNS

Those born into money like Prince William may be more sensitive to the plight of the poor than those who've made it from bad beginnings, scientists say.

The second in line to the throne was photographed earlier this month selling copies of The Big Issue to highlight homelessness.

And now a new study shows that people who go from rags to riches may be less likely to sympathize with the struggles of poverty than those who were born rich.

This runs contrary to the popular belief that coming from a privileged background makes you more indifferent to the economic plight of others.

The current study, published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, found that because those who struggled to become rich had moved up the economic ladder, they tended to see social mobility as being easier and had less sympathy for those unable to follow them.

Prince Harry greeting people (Wikimedia Commons)

The lead author of the study, Hyunjin Koo of the University of California, explained the disparity: “There are all sorts of stories and cultural narratives about the rich, what they’re like and how they behave.

“Our findings suggest that not all rich people may be the same. What seems to make a difference is how they got rich.

“In the United States, we find that people expect those who became rich to be more sympathetic toward the poor and social welfare than those who were born rich.

“However, the Became Rich perceive improving one’s socioeconomic conditions as less difficult relative to the Born Rich, which predicts less sympathetic attitudes toward the poor and redistribution.

“Just because someone has been in your shoes, doesn’t necessarily mean they care about you."

“Overcoming a certain difficulty may, by its very nature, cause people to be less sympathetic toward those experiencing that same difficulty because they overcame it.”

It is something that the general public doesn't seem to understand, as in one public survey, 27 percent of respondents said they admired the rich but that figure rose to 88 percent when respondents were asked if they admired those who had earned their money.

The team carried out five different studies as part of their research.

The first one surveyed 736 people in the US and found that people viewed the Became Rich more positively than the Born Rich and expected them to be more supportive of the poor and of social welfare.

This held true despite being told how hardworking people were in the two rich groups, the second study found.

Researchers conducted two further surveys of 1,032 wealthy individuals, with annual incomes of $80,000 in one study and $142,501 in the other.

It was here they discovered that those who became rich thought of social mobility as being easier and therefore had less sympathy with those unable to change their predicament.

In a final study, the researchers asked 492 people to imagine themselves in a hypothetical company.

They were randomly assigned into two groups, one whose members rose through the ranks and one where people were given top jobs from the beginning.

The results showed that participants in the upwardly mobile group thought it was easier to get ahead and therefore had less sympathy with those still struggling.

However, the researchers said it is too early to make any definitive conclusions about how upward mobility affects how people think, saying more research is needed.

Mr. Koo said: “There are likely many wealthy people who do not match the patterns we document who are sympathetic toward the poor and social welfare.”

He added that this research suggests people should consider the cultural narratives surrounding the two wealthy groups and that social mobility may have unexpected social downsides, causing those who have achieved success to be less sympathetic toward others who are struggling.

He also said he would like to do more research on how race and gender could affect this perception and to do similar surveys outside the US.

Stories and infographics by ‘Talker Research’ are available to download & ready to use. Stories and videos by ‘Talker News’ are managed by SWNS. To license content for editorial or commercial use and to see the full scope of SWNS content, please email licensing@swns.com or submit an inquiry via our contact form.

Top Talkers